So I'm mainly posting because I found a solution that allowed me to get the bucket hat and complete the Appleseed quests. What I did was the first quest where you give whatever you can to their camp then I smacked a dude around with a bucket hat on til he dropped it so I can snatch it up. After that I just ran away and saved. The only ones that should be glowing on the ground all the time are your current hat or hats that are on the "stolen" list, and they should automatically be added to your wardrobe. It took me until the epilogue to figure it out, lol Edit: Google "all stolen hats rdr2" a few sites have full lists with guides. I had this bug. I found a random hat on the ground put that on. Then I went and bought a new hat. Save the new hat to the horse. Then I went and cycled through each hat on the horse putting each one on and taking it off. Go to sleep and take a look when you wake up. It should disappear after going through multiple hats. Product Deals. See All. Amazon. $19.93 new. For Red Dead Redemption 2 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Bullet hole in hat not going away". Red Dead Redemption 2 foreshadows the Van der Linde gang's demise and how Dutch betrayed Arthur Morgan, John Marston, and Hosea Matthews. Red Dead Redemption 2 showcases the Van der Linde gang’s fall from grace and foreshadows the decline of its leader, Dutch, early on. There are rare moments during the game’s main story when players Rockstar's latest patch for Red Dead Redemption 2, 1.0.1436.31 has caused many popular RDR2 modifications to stop working. This is expected for game updates, but this particular patch has caused slightly more problems than usual. In this article, we discuss what's updated, what's not and what you need to do to get your mods working again. Arthur reiterates that Micah is the rat and says that he always did his best for Dutch and that John was the only one who made it, while Micah picks up his other revolver from the ground and begs Dutch to go with him and get the money. In the end, Dutch walks away, abandoning both Micah and Arthur. High Honor: Angered at Dutch's decision to cut You can take the mountain man's raccoon hat in Valentine, it's labeled as "classic raccoon hat" It's bigger than the others and has a more of a gray and black tail. Sheep herders also have a lootable hat that has the biggest brim next to the Ram's Sombrero from the trapper. Idk if it depends on your shot and if you didn't damage their hat, some jhc7.